Iryna Valiavko. S. Freud and psychoanalysis in Ukraine (first half of 20th century)

THE PHENOMENON OF RECEPTION IN THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY

Keywords: S. Freud, psychoanalytic movement, periods and centres of development of psychoanalysis in Ukraine, Freudian-Marxism, applied psychoanalysis, , continuity of ideas, Ukrainian psychoanalysis

Abstract

The article examines the history of the development and perception of S. Freud's concepts in Ukraine in the first half of the twentieth century. The author notes that the history of psychoanalysis has been removed from our historical and cultural memory for many years, and the works of Ukrainian psychoanalysts in the Soviet era have entirely fallen out of scientific circulation. However, at the beginning of the twentieth century, psychoanalysis started developing quite successfully in Ukraine and had prospects for further development and deepening. The author examines four main centres for the spread of psychoanalysis in Ukraine in the first half of the twentieth century: Kyiv, Odesa, Kharkiv and Lviv and highlights their peculiarities. It also analyzes four periods of the spread and development of psychoanalysis on the territory of Ukraine: 1. The perception and spread of psychoanalysis (1900-1917); 2. Creative development and rethinking of psychoanalysis in Ukraine (20s-early 30s); 3. Criticism and Prohibition of Psychoanalysis (the 30s); 4. The underground or "latent" period of psychoanalysis (30-50's). In conclusion, the author states that theoretical ideas of psychoanalysis have received their recognition and understanding and can be considered as a phenomenon of Ukrainian cultural and national life. Among our pioneer psychoanalysts, there were quite a lot of talented scientist and practicing psychiatrists, writers, and artists who left us their creative, scientific, archival heritage to be studied, analyzed and introduced into modern psychoanalytic discourse. The works of Ivan Franko, Stepan Balei, Valerian Pidmohylnyi, Yakim Yarema, Selvestr Haievskyi, Abram Khaletskii, Yakiv Kogan show us the beginning of the development of Ukrainian psychoanalysis, the beginning of creative research and approach to the problem of the unconscious.

Author Biography

Iryna Valiavko

Candidate of Sciences in Philosophy, Senior Research Fellow at the Department of History of Philosophy in Ukraine, H.S. Skovoroda Institute of Philosophy, NAS of Ukraine

4, Triokhsviatytelska St., Kyiv, 02000

References

Apter, I.M. (1929). Sexual neurosis and their therapy. [In Russian] Kharkiv.

Asmus, V.F. (1990). Philosophy at Kyiv University in 1914-1920. [In Russian] Voprosy filosofii, 8, 90-108.

Balei, S. (2002). On the psychology of Shevchenko's creative activity. [In Ukrainian] In: Collected works: In 5 vols. (vol. 1, pp. 174-210). Lviv, Odesa: IFLIS LFS "Cogito".

Bergler, Ye. (1923). Psychoanalysis. The essence and importance of prof. Freud's learning. [In Ukrainian]. Chervonyi Shliakh, Kharkiv, 6/7, 119-135.

Birshtein, I.A. (1913). V.M. Garshin's dream: A neuropsychiatric sketch on the issue of suicide. [In Russian]. Psikhoterapia, 4, 221-234.

Classical Psychoanalysis and Belles-Lettres (2002). [In Russian]. St. Petersburg: Piter.

Droznes, L.М. (1907). The tasks of medicine in the fight against modern nervousness. [In Russian]. Odessa.

Droznes, L.M. (1911). On masturbation. A popular view of the prof. Freud's psychoanalytic school on the essence of masturbation and its treatment. [In Russian] St. Petersburg.

Drosnes, L.M. (1914). Bio-psychological basis of the mental patients' delirium. [In Russian] Terapevticheskoe Obozrenie, 4.

Droznes, L.M., Skalkovskii, G.A. (1925). The Basics of the Process of Individual and Collective Development Determinated by environment. [In Russian]. Odesa.

Etkind, A.M. (1993). Eros of the Impossible: A History of Psychoanalysis in Russia. [In Russian]. Sanct-Petersburg: Meduza.

Ferenczi, S. (1925). Introjection and transference. [In Russian] Odesa.

Franco, I. (1981). Some of the secrets of poetic creativity.[In Ukrainian]. In: I. Franco, Collected works: in 50 vols. T. 31: I. Franko's Literary-Critical Works (1897-1899) (pp. 45-120). Kyiv: Naukova dumka.

Freud, A. (1927). Introduction to the technique of child psychoanalysis. [In Russian] Odesa.

Freud, S. (1912). Delirium and dreams in Jensen's "Gradive". In: W. Jensen, Gradiva. Fantastic adventures in Pompeii. [In Russian] Odesа: Zhizn' i dusha.

Freud, S. (1919). Essay on the history of psychoanalysis. [In Russian] Odesa: Psikhe.

Freud, S. (1923). Essay on the history of psychoanalysis. In: S. Freud, Basic psychological theories in psychoanalysis (pp. 17-75). [In Russian] Moscow, Petrograd: State Publishing House.

Freud, S. (1926). Psychoanalytic studies. [In Russian] Odesa: Poligraph.

Gakkebush, V.M. (1925). On criticism of the modern application of the psychoanalytic method of treatment. [In Russian]. Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 8, 89-96.

Gakkebush, V.M. (1926). Response to the Chairman of the Russian Psychoanalytic Society, Dr. M.V. Vulf. [In Russian]. Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 2 (3), 359-360.

Geimanovich, A.I. (1910). On the psychoanalytic method of treating neurosis (according to Freud). [In Russian] Kharkovskii Meditsinskii Zhurnal, 6, 44-56.

Guber-Grits, D.S. (1926). Hypnosis as a psychoanalytic method in reflexological theory coverage. [In Russian] Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 2 (3), 311-323.

Haievskyi, S. (1926). Freudism in Literary Studies. [In Ukrainian] Hzyttia i Revolutsia, 10, 70-75.

Jung, C. (1923). The conflict of the child's soul. [In Russian] Put' Prosveshchenia, 1, 115-142.

Khaletskii, A.M. (1926). Psychoanalysis of Shevchenko's personality and creative actiiivity. [In Russian] Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 2 (3), 347-354.

Khaletskii, A.M. (1927). On the question of the sexual symbolism of the delirium of the mental patients. [In Russian] Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 2, 133-139.

Khaletskii, A.M. (1928). On the psychology of hooliganism. [In Russian] In: Crime Studies and Penitentiary Practice (vol. 2, pp. 5-28). Odesa.

Kogan, Ya.M. (1926). Identification and its role in artistic creation. [In Russian] In: Questions of the theory and practice of psychoanalysis. Odessa.

Kogan, Ya.M. (1927a). An associative experiment as applied to the study of the identity of the offender личности преступника. [In Russian] In: Crime Studies and Penitentiary Practice (vol. 1, pp. 40-54). Odesa.

Kogan, Ya.M. (1927b). Some parallels of libidinous development in phylogeny and ontogeny. [In Ukrainian] Etnografichnyi visnyk, 5, 202-215.

Kogan, Ya.M. (1928). About the tattoo of criminals. [In Russian] In: Crime Studies and Prison Practice (vol. 2, pp. 53-112). Odessa.

Kogan, Ya.M. (1935). On the manifestation of the Oedipus complex in schizophrenia. [In Russian] In: The Anniversary collection dedicated to the 35th anniversary of the Odesa Psychiatric Hospital (pp. 1-10). Odesa: Publishing House of the Odesa Medical Institute.

Kogan, Ya.M. (1941). On the structure of paraphrenic diseases. [In Russian] Odesa: Publishing House of the Odesa Medical Institute.

Likhnitskii, V.N. (1912). Psikhoterapia i Psikhoanaliz. [In Russian]. Odesa.

Malis, G. (1924). The psychoanalysis of communism. (Preface by K.I. Platonov). [In Russian] Kharkiv: Kosmos.

Malis, G. (1929). The Paths of Psychology. [In Russian] Leningrad: Publishing House «Rabotnik prosveshchenia»

Mokulskyi, K.S. (1931). Discussion questions and problems of the doctrine of behavior. [In Ukrainian]. Komunistychna Osvita, 5/6, 69-83.

Pavlychko, S. (2002). Literature theory. [In Ukrainian] Kyiv: Osnovy.

Perlin, M. (1926). Freudism and Marxism. [In Ukrainian] Zhuttia i Revolutsia, 4, 108-113; 6, 80-87.

Perlin, Ye. (1927). Again about Freudism and the arts. [In Ukrainian] Zhuttia i Revolutsia, 9, 287-294.

Pidmohylnyi, V. (1927). Ivan Levitsky-Nechuy: An attempt at psychoanalysis of creativity. [In Ukrainian]. Zhyttia i Revolutsia, 9, 295-303.

Raikh, W. (1922). Dialectical materialism and psychoanalysis. [In Russian] Pod Znamieniem Marksizma, 7-8, 180-206.

Romenets, V.A. (1967). On the issue of Freudism and its criticism in Ukraine. [In Ukrainian]. In: On the History of Philosophy in Ukraine (pp. 135-143). Kyiv: Naukova Dumka.

Ryzhkov, V.N. (1922). Psychoanalysis as a system of education. [In Russian] Put' Prosveshchenia, Kharkiv, 6, 96-218.

https://doi.org/10.1177/002205742209600816

Smirnov, D.A. (1927). General pedology. [In Russian] Dnepropetrovsk: Dino.

The Freud-Jung Letters (1974). The Correspondence Between Sigmund Freud and C.G. Jung. Londres. Retrieved from: http://www.scribd.com/doc/78404737

The History of Psychoanalysis in Ukraine (Comp. I.I. Kutko, L.I. Bondarenko, P.T. Petryuk) (1996). [In Russian] Kharkiv: Osnovy.

Valiavko, I. (2017). Homeland and origins of Ukrainian psychoanalysis. [In Russian]. Psikhoanaliz, 1 (20), 139-159.

Valiavko, I. (2018) On the problem of «national identity». [In Ukrainian]. Ucrainica Mediaevalia, Kyiv, 1, 103-109

Vulf, M.V. (1909). About the psychoanalytic method of treatment (Freud's Theory). [In Russian] Terapevticheskoe Obozrenie, 7, 159-168.

Vulf, M.V. (1911). A critical review of German psychoanalytic literature in 1909. [In Russian] Psikhoterapia, 4/5, 22-31.

Vulf, M.V. (1925). On the psychoanalysis of coquetry. [In Russian] Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 3-4, 33-43.

Vulf, M.V. (1926a). In memory of Dr. C. Abraham. [In Russian]. Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 2 (2), 218-222.

Vulf, M.V. (1926b). Fantasy and reality in the psyche of a child. [In Russian] Odesa.

Vulf M.V. (1926c). Open letter to the editor. [In Russian] Sovremiennaia Psikhonevrologia, 2 (3), 354-359.

Vulf, M.V. (1929). Psychology of children's whims. [In Russian] In: Questions of the theory and practice of psychoanalysis. Odesa.

Vygotskii, L.S., Luria, A.R. (1989). Preface to the Russian translation of "Beyond the Principle of Pleasure". [In Russian] In: S. Freud, Psychology of the unconscious. Moscow: Prosveshchenie.

Yarema, Ya. (1933). Children's Experiences and Creative Activity of Shevchenko from the Position of Psychoanalysis. [In Ukrainian] Lviv: Uchytelʹsʹka hromada.

Yaroshevskyi, K. (1925). Psychoanalysis and its place in modern psychology. [In Ukrainian] Zhyttia I Revolutsia, 6/7, 77-81.

Yurinets, V.A. (1924). Freudianism and Marxism. [In Russian] Pid Praporom Marksyzmu, 8-9, 51-93.

Published
2020-06-23
How to Cite
Valiavko, I. (2020). Iryna Valiavko. S. Freud and psychoanalysis in Ukraine (first half of 20th century). Filosofska Dumka, (2), 65-85. https://doi.org/10.15407/fd2020.02.065
Section
TOPIC OF THE ISSUE