Post-Colonial Studies and Ukrainian Marxism

ARTICLES: WHY MARX? Return to the Subject

  • Serhii Hrabovsky
Keywords: colonialism, Ukrainian Marxism, post-colonial studies, social criticism, national-communism, imperialism, European-type colony

Abstract

The article is devoted to Ukrainian Marxism, its initial stages of development and one of its main areas — anti-colonial and postcolonial research. It continues the discussion on the round table Ideology and Utopia. The Legacy of Marxism and Modern Political Reality (FD, No. 2, 2018). The author notes the attempts of the Ukrainian Marxists to adapt Marx’s and Engels’s main ideas to domestic realities and to criticize a number of these ideas.

The article outlines main achievements of the Ukrainian Marxists in terms of anti- colonial and post-colonial studies. Julian Bachinsky in 1895 in the book Ukraine Irredenta substantiated the objective need to overcome the colonial status of Ukrainian lands and to create Ukrainian independent state.

In 1919, Serhiy Mazlach and Vasyl Shakhray published the book, named To the Wave. In it they wrote that industrial capitalism turned Eastern Ukraine into a developed Russian colony, and its inhabitants — into a modern nation. It prepared the ground for making Ukraine independent.

The expanded political and economic study of the phenomenon of colonialism and the substantiation of the status of Ukraine as one of the “European-type colonies” was given by Mikhaylo Volobuev-Artemov in the article On the Problem of the Ukrainian Eco- nomy, published in the journal Bolshevik of Ukraine (2-3, 1928). Volobuyev stressed: if in the USSR Ukraine will not become a separate economic unit, it will again turn into a colony.

The author believes that the experience of Ukrainian neo-Marxism, which did not simplify the problems of colonialism, reducing it to a racial factor, is very relevant. The ideological resource of postcolonial studies, understanding Ukraine’s specifics as “Euro- pean-type colony” is urgently needed today for in-depth reforms.

Author Biography

Serhii Hrabovsky

candidate of sciences in philosophy, senior research fellow, Department of Philosophical Problems of Ethnic and Nation, H.S. Skovoroda Institute of Philosophy, National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine

References

Azerbaijan SSR (1926). [in Russian] The Great Soviet Encyclopedia (vol. 1, pp. 638-666). Moscow: ООО «Sovetskaya entsiklopedia».

Baratashvili Nikolay Melitonovich (1926). The Great Soviet Encyclopedia (vol. 3, pp. 693-695). Moscow: ООО «Sovetskaya entsiklopedia». [= Бараташвили 1926]

Bachynsky, Ю. (1924). Ukraine irredenta. [in Ukrainian]. Berlin: Vydavnytstvo Ukrainskoi molodi. [= Бачинський 1924]

Volobuev, М. (s.a.). On the Problem of Ukrainian Economy. [in Ukrainian] Retrieved from: https:// vpered.wordpress.com/2013/02/04/volobuev-ukrainian-economy/.[= Волобуєв s.a.]. Hrabovsky, S. (2017). Colonial Wars of the Second Rech Pospolyta. [in Ukrainian] Kyiv: Тovarystvо «Znannya Ukrainy». [= Грабовський 2017]

Hrytsak, Ya. (s.a.). The End of Revolution? [In Ukrainian]Retrieved from: http://gazeta.ua/arti-

cles/grycak-jaroslav/_kinec-revolyuciyi/751588. [= Грицак (s.a.)].

Dziuba, І. (1998). Do We Realize the National Culture as the Integrity. [in Ukrainian]. Suchasnist,

, 92-109. [= Дзюба 1998].

Zheliabov, А. (s.a.). Speech of Andrei Ivanovich Zhelyabov at the Trial in Connection with the

Prosecution on March 1,1881. [in Russian]. Retrieved from: http://vivovoco.rsl.ru/VV/

PAPERS/HISTORY/REVOL/SPEECH.HTM. [= Желябов].

Mazlakh, S., Shakh-Ray, V. (1919). To the Wave. (What Happens in Ukraine and with Ukraine?).

[in Ukrainian] Saratov: Sovitska typografiya, 5 viddil.[= Мазлах 1919]

Marx, K. Capital, vol.1 (s.a.(a)). [in Russian] In: Marx, K., Engels, F. Works, 23, 20. [= Маркс

(s.a.(a)).]

Marx, K. Capital, (s.a.(b)), Vol. 3. [in Russian]. In: Marx, K., Engels, F. Works, 25 (1), [ =

Маркс (s.a.(b))].

Podolynsky, С. (2002). Letter to V.N. Smirnov to London. [in Ukrainian] In: Serhiy Podolynsky.

Letters and Documents,compiled: R. Serbin, Т. Slyudikova. Kyiv: Tsentralny derzhavny isto-

rychny arkhiv Ukrainy. [= Подолинський 2002]

Program of the Ukrainian Communist Party (s.a.). [in Ukrainian] Retrieved from: https://vpered.

wordpress.com/2009/11/27/ukr-comm-party-prog/. [= Програма s.a.]

Richytsky, А. (1928). Tsentralna Rada from February to October. Essay from the History of

Ukrainian Revolution. [in Ukrainian] Kharkiv: Derzhvydav Ukrainy. [= Річицький 1928] Riabchuk, М. (s.a.). I Do not state that we are doomed to “cold” or even worse to “hot” civil war. [in Ukrainian] Retrieved from: https://zaxid.net/mikola_ryabchuk_ya_ne_stverdzhuyu_ shho_mi_prirecheni_na_holodnu_chi_shhe_girshe_garyachu_gromadyansku_viynu_

n1127321. [ = Рябчук (s.a.)]. Riabchuk, М. (2011). Postcolonial Syndrome. Observations. [in Ukrainian] Kyiv: K.І.S. [= Рябчук 2011].

Tompson, Е.М. (2006). Troubadours of the Empire. Russian Literature and Colonialism. [in Ukrainian] Kyiv: Publ. House of Solomiya Pavlychko “Osnovy”. [= Томпсон 2006] Trotskii, L. (s.a.). On the Ukrainian Problem. [inRussian] Retrieved from: http://www.magister.

msk.ru/library/trotsky/trotm465.htm. [ = Троцкий (s.a.)].

Franko, І. (s.a.(a)) Ukraina irredenta: Mosaic from the Works Which Have not Entered in Collected

Works in 50 Volumes. [in Ukrainian] Retrieved from: http://www.myslenedrevo.com.ua/

studies/franko/mosaic/31.html. [ = Франко (s.a.(a))].

Franko, І. (s.a.(b)) What Is Progress? [in Ukrainian] Retrieved from: http://m.ukrclassic.com.ua/

katalog/f/franko-ivan/2123-ivan-franko-shcho-take-postup?start=6. [ = Франко (s.a.(b))]. Khmelnytsky Bogdan Zinovii Mikhailovich (1935). [in Russian]. The Great Soviet Encyclopedia

(vol. 59, pp. 816-818). Moscow: OGIZ SSSR.

Shapoval, Yu. (1994). «I Was Mistaken Taking the Blame on Myself...» (On the 90th Birthday of

M.S. Volobuyev-Artemov). [in Russian] From Archives of VUCHK-GPU-NKVD-KGB, 1 (1),

pp.104-110. [ = Шаповал 1994].

Engels, F. (1962). Foreign Policy of Russian Tzarizm (pp. 11-52). [in Russian]. In: Marx, K.,

Engels, F. Works (Vol. 22, pp. 11-52). Moscow: Gosudarstvennoye izdatelstvo politicheskoi

literatury. [= Энгельс 1962].

Anderson, B. (1991). Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.

Category: Former Russian colonies (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cate-

gory:Former_Russian_colonies.

Colony (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colony.

Moore, D.Ch. (2001). Is the Post- in Postcolonial the Post- in Post-Soviet? Toward a Global

Postcolonial Critique. PMLA, 116 (1), 111–128.

Published
2020-07-14
How to Cite
Hrabovsky, S. (2020). Post-Colonial Studies and Ukrainian Marxism. Filosofska Dumka, (4), 53-70. Retrieved from https://dumka.philosophy.ua/index.php/fd/article/view/427