FREEDOM OF RELIGION IN UKRAINE: CHALLENGES DURING THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINIAN WAR
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.15407/fd2023.01.111Keywords:
Freedom of religion, Russian-Ukrainian war, violation of religious freedom, legislation of Ukraine in the socio-religious sphere, OSCE document 2019 «Freedom of Religion or Belief and Security»Abstract
The article is updated by several circumstances, which the authors reflect on. In their opinion, there are 1) obvious and external threats — violations of freedom of conscience in the temporarily occupied Ukrainian territories, including Crimea, which arose as a result of the Russian-Ukrainian war, and 2) internally hidden and potential dangers for freedom of religions of Ukrainian citizens.
The well-known examples of discrimination of believers of certain faiths in the so-called DPR-LPR and Crimea given by the authors are constantly updated. Relevant monitoring and analytical reports are prepared by both Ukrainian and international experts. They submitted these reports to international human rights organizations, including the rights for Freedom of Religion and Belief.
Despite such convincing documented materials, separate accusations have recently appeared against Ukraine, which allegedly violates freedom of religion in the territory under its control. Some are trying to prove that Ukraine, taking advantage of the war situation and referring to the spiritual dangers for Ukraine from those religious organizations whose centers are in the aggressor country, threatens some churches, thereby violating the Constitution and the Law on Freedom of Conscience, which guarantee for all citizens, regardless of from their religious affiliation, freedom of religion.
The authors refute these narratives lashed out by Russia and the Russian Orthodox Church. Such negative conclusions, which express concern about the situation in Ukraine regarding freedom of conscience and religion, influence on the world public, experts on issues of freedom of conscience, religious organizations, spoil the image of Ukraine as a country with high level of freedom of conscience even among European countries.
Religious freedom, as the authors conclude, needs protection today, but they call for separating real threats from imaginary ones and clearly defining who persecutes, whom he/she persecutes and where persecutes. Ukraine is consistent in its intentions to protect the rights of people and communities, to protect the freedoms of believers and their organizations.
References
Acting Chairman of the SBU about hostile threats in the activities of the UOC (MP): 33 suspected agents and fire adjusters in cassocks (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://interfax. com.ua/news/general/868335.html
Cabinet of Ministers Cabinet approved sanctions against Patriarch Kirill and other representatives of the Russian Orthodox Church (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://df.news/ 2022/08/30/kabmin-skhvalyv-skhvalyv-sanktsii-proty-patriarkha-kirila-ta-inshykh-pred- stavnykiv-rpts/
Conclusion of the religious examination of the Statute on the Administration of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church on the existence of a church-canonical connection with the Moscow Patriarchate (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://dess.gov.ua/vysnovok-relihiieznavchoi-ek-spertyzy-statutu-pro-upravlinnia-upc/
Constitutional Court of Ukraine passed a Decision in the case regarding the full name of religious organizations ..., concluding that the amendments to Article 12 of the Law of Ukraine «On Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations» are constitutional (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://ccu.gov.ua/novyna/konstytuciynyy-sud-ukrayiny-uhvalyv- rishennya-u-spravi-shchodo-povnoyi-nazvy-religiynyh
Correctors in cassocks: the SBU exposed 33 agents in the ranks of the UOC MP - Maliuk (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://suspilne.media/303934-koriguvalniki-u-rasah-sbu- vikrila-33-agentiv-u-lavah-upc-mp-maluk/
Crimean human rights group (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://crimeahrg.org/uk/
Cyril blessed. In the Kyiv region, the occupiers burned sacred books (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://glavcom.ua/kyiv/news/kirilo-blagosloviv-na-kijivshchini-okupanti-spalili- svyashchenni-knigi-foto-837084.html
Decision of the National Security Council and the Presidential Decree do not mention the prohibition of the UOC (s.a.). It is about protecting religious organizations registered in Ukraine from the influence of the aggressor country. [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://dess.gov.ua/ v-rishenni-rnbo-i-ukazi-prezydenta-ne-ydetsia-pro-zaboronu-upts
Decree of the President of Ukraine No. 820/2022. On the decision of the National Security and Defen- se Council of Ukraine dated December 1, 2022 ... (s.a.). «On certain aspects of the activities of religious organizations in Ukraine and the application of personal special economic and other restrictive measures (sanctions)». [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://www.president. gov.ua/documents/8202022-45097
Donetsk Christian University became a Russian military base (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://informnapalm.org/ua/donetskyj-hrystyyanskyj-universytet-stav-rosijskoyu- vijskovoyu-bazoyu/
Draft 7213 of the Law on Amendments to the Law of Ukraine «On Freedom of Conscience and Reli- gious Organizations» ... (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/bill- Info/Bills/Card/39269
Draft 8012 Resolution on the appeal of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine to the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine regarding the transfer to the Orthodox Church of Ukraine for free use of the complexes of buildings of the Pochaiv Assumption Lavra and the Kyiv-Pechersk Lavra (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/40437
Draft 8221 of the Law on ensuring strengthening of national security in the sphere of freedom of con- science and activities of religious organizations (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https:// itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/40832
Draft 8262 of the Law on Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on Improving the Legal Regulation of the Activities of Religious Organizations (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/40938
Draft 8371 of the Law on Amendments to Certain Laws of Ukraine Regarding the Activities of Re- ligious Organizations in Ukraine (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://itd.rada.gov. ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/41219
Freedom of Religion or Belief - FoRB (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://hrwf.eu/forb/
Freedom of Religion or Belief - FoRB (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://hrwf.eu/forb/
Freedom of religion or belief and security. Guiding principles (2019). [In Ukrainian]. Religious freedom, 22-23, 67-78.
https://doi.org/10.32420/rs.2019.22-23.1660
Freedom of religion under fire (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://irs.in.ua/files/publications/2018.10.24-IRF-Report-UKR.pdf
Fylypovych, L. (2016). Freedom of religion and belief in the report of the US State Department. [In Ukrainian]. In: Religious freedom: freedom of religion and belief under the conditions of modern challenges. Scientific yearbook. Ed. by prof. A. Kolodnyi, prof. L. Fylypovych (part 2, pp. 25-28). Kyiv: UAR.
https://doi.org/10.32420/rs.2016.19.2.887
Human rights without frontiers (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://hrwf.eu
Impact of the Russian invasion on the religious communities of Ukraine (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://irf.in.ua/files/publications/2022.09-IRF-Ukraine-report-summary-UKR.pdf
In Irpen, orcs burned thousands of Bibles (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://risu.ua/v-irpeni-orki-spalili-tisyachi-biblij_n128119
IRFSummit2023 (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://www.facebook.com/hashtag/irfsummit2023
IRS presented a study in the US about Russian attacks on religious communities in Ukraine (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://irs.in.ua/p/122
IRS presented data on Russian attacks on religious communities in Ukraine in the United States (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://irs.in.ua/p/128
It is difficult to ban with one law: what to do with the UOC MP (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=izEkJgzsKbM
«It is impossible to ban the Church (UPC MP), almost all members of the expert group are on this position», - Liudmyla Fylypovych (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: http://radiomaria. org.ua/zaboroniti-cerkvu-upc-mp-nemojlivo-maije-vsi-chleni-ekspertno-gru-pi-stoyat-na-cii-pozici-lyudmila-filipovich-12617
Law of Ukraine On Amendments to Article 12 of the Law of Ukraine «On Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations» regarding the name of religious organizations (associations) ... (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2662-19#Text
Legal opinion regarding the possibility of a legal ban or termination of the activities of the Russian Orthodox Church and Ukrainian Orthodox Church in Ukraine (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Re- trieved from: https://risu.ua/pravovij-visnovok-shchodo-mozhlivosti-pravovoyi-zaboroni-abo-pripinennya-diyalnosti-rpc-ta-upc-v-ukrayini_n129295
Locked faith. Голос віруючих під час війни (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://locked- faith.org/ua
Maliuk about the UOC MP: We must clear the environment of enemy moles in cassocks (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2022/12/21/7381715/
Meeting of the UN Security Council due to the «oppression» of the UOC (MP) (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://df.news/2023/01/18/zasidannia-radbezu-oon-cherez-utysky-upts-mp-shcho-vidpovily-frantsiia-ta-kytaj/
Metropolitan Mark of Berlin spoke in support of the UOC (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://spzh.news/ua/news/70298-mitropolit-berlinskij-mark-vistupiv-iz-pidtrim-koju-upts
Metropolitan Pavlo accused the «powerful Herods» of «persecution», and called Epiphanius «the devil and self-sacrilegion» (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://vsn.in.ua/news/mitropolit- pavlo-zvinuvativ-vladnih-irodiv-u-goninnyah-a-epifaniya-nazvav-bisom-i-samosvya- tom-video-17413
Moscow church went to complain to the UN (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://glavcom. ua/news/moskovska-tserkva-pishla-zhalitisja-v-oon-mitropolit-onufrij-poterpaje-vid- relihijnoji-diskriminatsiji-905391.html
Nikolay Mitrokhin. January 6 (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://www.facebook.com/nikolay.mitrokhin.1 Occupiers are taking Ukrainian books from the libraries in order to destroy them - the adviser to the mayor of Mariupol (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://life.pravda.com.ua/
culture/2022/05/25/248802/
Religion during the Russian-Ukrainian Conflict (2019). Ed. by E. Clark, D. Vovk. S.l.: Routledge. Religion in fire (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://www.mar.in.ua/en/religion-on-fire/
Republicans in the US Congress registered the «Resolution on fatigue with Ukraine» (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://suspilne.media/380945-respublikanci-u-kongresi-ssa-za-reestruvali-resoluziu-pro-vtomu-vid-ukraini/
Russian attack on religious freedom in Ukraine (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://irs.in.ua/p/118
Russian attack on religious freedom in Ukraine. Research. Analytics. Recommendations (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://irf.in.ua/files/publications/2022.09-IRF-Ukraine-report-UKR.pdf
Russian fighters from the ORDLO captured the Taurian Christian Institute in Kherson (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://slovoproslovo.info/rosiyski-biytsi-z-ordlo-zahopili-tavriyskiy-hristiyanskiy-institut-u-hersoni
Russians removed all Ukrainian books from Melitopol libraries (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from:
Sagan, O. (2022). «Prohibition» of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Russian Orthodox Church of Ukraine (ROCVU): are sanctions against Ukraine necessary or a result? [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://risu.ua/zaborona-upc-mp-rpcvu-potribni-sankciyi-proti-ukrayini- chi-rezultat
Summary table of the list of religious organizations that are subject to Part 7 of Article 12 of the Law of Ukraine «On Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations» (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://ukurier.gov.ua/media/files/2019-1/вси%20сторинки_.pdf
They will be destroyed: the occupiers are removing all books related to Ukraine from the Donbas li- braries (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://www.unian.ua/war/okupanti-viluch- ayut-z-bibliotek-donbasu-knigi-z-istoriji-ukrajini-novini-vtorgnennya-rosiji-v-ukra- jinu-11841468.html
Trump Jr. stood up for the UOC-MP (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://risu.ua/tramp-molodshij-zastupivsya-za-upc-mp_n134541
UKRAINE: Almost 500 religious sites destroyed as a result of Russian aggression (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://hrwf.eu/ukraine-almost-500-religious-sites-destroyed-as-a-result-of-russian- aggression/
UKRAINE: With Orthodoxy torn apart in Ukraine, mediation is needed to heal it (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://hrwf.eu/ukraine-with-orthodoxy-torn-apart-in-ukraine-mediation-is-needed-to- heal-it/
Ukrainian Orthodox Church did not ask the Russian Orthodox Church to intercede for them at the UN (s.a.). [In Ukrainian]. Retrieved from: https://df.news/2023/01/17/v-upts-mp-kazhut-shcho-ne-prosyly-rosiian-za-nykh-zastupatys-v-oon/
Video-Botschaft des Metropoliten Mark zur neuerlich versch rften Kirchenverfolgung in der Ukraine (s.a.). Retrieved from: https://www.derbote.online/post/metropolit-mark-zu-kirchenver-folgung-ukraine?fbclid=IwAR
Downloads
-
PDF (Українська)
Downloads: 242
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).